Up until this point, the title of this post was true. No matter how slim, obscure, complicated, easy, gorgeous, or ugly a cookbook was, I always found something in them that I liked, and usually loved. But I'm afraid that my most recent cookbook purchase has been a major disappointment. What makes it even more of a disappointment is that I am trying to limit my cookbook purchasing. My cookbook bookcase is all filled, plus I have more recipes marked to try than there are days left in my life!
But when I bought my new slow cooker, I purchased "Not Your Mother's Slow Cooker Cookbook" by Beth
Hensperger and Julie
Kaufmann. Even though, I had found over 6,000 recipes on the
internet, I thought it would be easier to have a book filled with recipes that I could turn to again and again. Instead of feeling the desire to turn to this book, I am feeling the desire to turn away. I have tried 3 recipes from it and all of them have been disappointing.
The first recipe I tried was a basic ham and beans, commonly called "Congressional or Senate Bean Soup". I have been making ham and beans for years and years and I've tried different versions along the way, and have pretty much liked them all, until now. This recipe was not awful, but it had a weird component. Some kind of off flavor. This recipe called for potatoes, which I didn't use, but I did use the 2 onions and 6 ribs of celery. That was a lot of onions and
alot of celery. Most recipes that I've used in the past called for one onion a rib or two of celery and usually a bay leaf.
The next recipe I tried was for a basic pot of beans. The beans called for a pound of dried beans, 1 clove of garlic, 1 onion, 1/2 a bay leaf (!), 1 teaspoon of dried oregano (or marjoram or savory), pinch of ground cumin and a pinch of ground coriander, and then water and chicken broth. These were okay, they were not very flavorful. One clove of garlic is not much for a big pot of beans, plus, why just 1/2 a bay leaf. Would one whole bay leaf overpower the flavor of the beans?
The last recipe I tried was for a "White Bean and Kale Tomato Soup". It wasn't until I was assembling the ingredients and looking at the instructions, that I realized that this also looked like it was not going to have much flavor. It tells you to cook vegetable broth, tomato puree, canned beans, rice, an onion, dried basil and salt and pepper, all day. Then 30 minutes before serving, you add cooked sausage and kale. I really don't understand this recipe. Why not at least use dried beans, so you could get some flavor from the beans? Why add the sausage last, when it doesn't have time to add much flavor? The rice thickened up and the soup had almost the consistency of tapioca with very little flavor. I compared it with a another recipe that I found on the
internet that called for dried beans, zucchini, red wine, and the sausage added at the beginning. That one sounds like it would be pretty good and I will try it next.
I am not giving up on this book, I have 2 more recipes marked to try this week. This is so disappointing because this is my third book by this author, I also have her bread machine cookbook and her rice cooker cookbook, both of which I love. So, I'm not giving up yet, but I have don't have a good feeling about this!